Warning: session_regenerate_id(): Cannot regenerate session id - session is not active in /var/app/current/include/config.php on line 142 Notice: Only variables should be assigned by reference in /var/app/current/include/config.php on line 148 Notice: Undefined variable: dontRegenToken in /var/app/current/include/config.php on line 275 Beistle Decorative Plush Pumpkin Pie Hat vs Plush Chef Turkey Hat from Beistle - Which Thanksgiving Hat Do You Prefer?

Versus

71%

Beistle Decorative Plush Pumpkin Pie Hat

Beistle Decorative Plush Pumpkin Pie Hat
If you like to be the center of attention at the holidays, you will want to pick up this piece of Pumpkin Pie hat. On Amazon, you will find this Beistle Decorative Plush Pumpkin Pie Hat for $11.99 with free shipping on orders over $25. You can also purchase a 3 pack, a 6 pack, or a 12 pack.

These hats are a festive way to show your love for the Thanksgiving holiday. Perhaps it could even start a tradition. Maybe each year for Thanksgiving, host a silly Thanksgiving hat party? Sort of like an Ugly Christmas Sweater party. This hat would be a great hat to wear as it is very soft and festive. It would look great on anyone!

Another great idea would be to purchase one of these for a photo booth. You see these all the time at weddings and other parties. Just a nice prop to add to the excitement of getting photos taken!

This hat is a one size fits most hat. The opening is shallow.

Pros
  • very festive
  • perfect for Thanksgiving
  • great for those that love to be funny
  • silly and humorous
  • soft
  • fun
  • great conversation starter
  • nice addition to a photo booth
  • good quality fabric
  • nice colors
  • unique
  • makes for a great laugh
  • decent price
  • adorable
  • stable on the head
  • makes a great gag gift
  • easy to wear
  • received many compliments
  • clever design
  • shiny fabric

Cons
  • arrived with no hole for the head
  • does not stand up like the image
  • arrived smashed
  • people were mistaken as they thought the pumpkin pie was sweet potato pie
  • does not stay on head very well
  • looks nothing like image
  • does not have any stuffing in it to make it look nice
  • not worth the money
  • does not retain shape well
  • opening was too shallow
  • poor quality
  • dark chocolate brown coloring on the sides, not the same color used as on the sides

Supporters

angie828

Yum Pumpkin Pie

I love pumpkin pie so when I see this hat, it makes me want a slice of it. I think that this hat would be very cute to wear on Thanksgiving. Not something that everyone would expect. They may expect you to wear a turkey hat, but a slice of pie on the head is genius.
Posted by angie828 on 11-07-2017
Mahshiemonalisa

so fun!

I love fun and silly things. Sometimes life just feels too serious and it's always nice to be around people who can lighten things up and make others laugh. It would be great to have someone at your Thanksgiving meal put on this silly pumpkin pie hat at dessert time. I am not a silly type of person, but I would love to buy this and have everyone take turns wearing it and laughing and taking pictures. What a great idea!
Posted by Mahshiemonalisa on 11-12-2017
Mehano

Love pumpkin pie

I don't think that I would personally wear either of these two hats but if I had to pick, I believe that this Beistle Decorative Plush Pumpkin Pie Hat is the better option.

I mean, who doesn't love pumpkin pie? So, why not show your love by wearing it on your head!

I really love the little details such as the whipped cream on top, very nice.

Posted by Mehano on 11-07-2017
kgord

Pumpkin Pie Hat

I like the Pumpkin Pie hat. It reminds me of the cheesehead hats they wear in Wisconsin to support the packers. I think the pie hat is good fun and would be a cool thing to wear for Thanksgiving. I would wear it.
Posted by kgord on 11-07-2017
felabruno

Funnier

Honestly both hats are cute and funny. I think it is a great idea to buy things for laugh sometimes. I choose the pie hat because it looks a bit better and because I love pie. I wouldn't mind buying the turkey one either.
Posted by felabruno on 11-08-2017

29%

Plush Chef Turkey Hat from Beistle

Plush Chef Turkey Hat from Beistle
This Plush Chef Turkey Hat from Beistle can be all yours for only $15.99 on Amazon. Shipping is free. This novelty hat is not only festive, but made from high quality materials. The hat features an adorable turkey wearing an apron and a chef's hat. The turkey is holding a fork. His feathers are brightly colored in fall colors of orange, yellow, and brown. His body features a soft fuzzy material. His legs dangle over the side of the face when worn.

This festive hat can be worn on Thanksgiving day by the chef to let everyone know who made the delicious meal. Or it would be great for someone to wear to a tacky hat party. It would be an equally amazing hat to wear to a Turkey Trot run.

This hat is sure to receive many compliments. It is comfortable to wear and is soft. The bright colors and funny turkey will make anyone smile.

Pros
  • super adorable
  • great for a turkey trot
  • affordable
  • soft
  • great quality
  • funny
  • receives lots of attention
  • great for tacky hat day or photo booths
  • arrived just as anticipated
  • stretchy
  • great company and customer service

Cons
  • fits smaller heads better
  • fork does not stand by itself
  • fork did not look like a fork
  • delivered smashed
  • fork was missing
  • did not stay on the head well
  • had a tendency to fall to one side
  • too heavy
  • poor quality
  • arrived with hole in the neck
  • threading was hanging from seams

Supporters

kingcool52

This

Neither really. I don't know why anyone would want to wear either on their head but if I had to choose then it would have to be this Plus Chef Turkey Hat from Beistle. I just feel like it would just look stupid and pointless to have a pumpkin pie hat on your head. I believe that it would make a lot more sense to have a turkey hat on your head during thanksgiving.
Posted by kingcool52 on 11-07-2017
Sue

Turkey hat

I think this is really cute and would be the hit at any Thanksgiving get together. After all what would a Thanksgiving get together be without a silly turkey hat? I think it is perfect and definitely something that i would wear.
Posted by Sue on 11-07-2017

Comments

Pixie
To be honest I don't like either one. I can't see myself wearing something like those for Thanksgiving. Those hats are weird looking. Moreover, I don't want to waste my money buying something that I will never use again. Furthermore, as stated in the thread above the hats are of poor quality. This is another turnoff.
Posted by Pixie on 11-07-2017
Tania997
Yeah, we don't celebrate Thanksgiving in my country but I never understood why would someone buy anything that you can wear only on that day. It's pretty much a waste of money and these hats are also of poor quality like you said. I'd never buy them, and that's why I'm not voting for either one of these.
Posted by Tania997 on 11-07-2017
ColdFlameChris
They're both a complete waste of money since those two looks horrible and not that appealing. I find it corny to wear and not a good idea to select as a Hat costume. I will never waste my money on something that is as ugly as those two and then you just gonna wear them like once per year. It's a complete waste of time and money.
Posted by ColdFlameChris on 11-07-2017
NickJ
Both pieces of head-wear look absurd and ridiculous. The most 'dressing up' I've ever done at Thanksgiving time was wearing a chef's apron while preparing Thanksgiving dinner. That's about it.
Posted by NickJ on 11-17-2017