Versus

54%

Peanut Butter Pie

Peanut Butter Pie
Imagine a creamy piece of peanut butter pie to compliment a delicious supper. A chocolate crust filled to the brim with a creamy peanut butter filling, topped with mounds of whipped cream. Then drizzled with either chocolate sauce, chocolate shavings, or crushed up peanut butter cups.

If you love pie and you have a thing for peanut butter, then peanut butter pie may be for you! One bite will leave you wanting more!

Pros
  • delicious
  • easy to make
  • creamy rich tasty

Cons
  • hard to eat on the go
  • some may not like the hard peanut butter cup pieces in the filling
  • needs to be frozen or refrigerated

Supporters

nekonieden

Pie

I think peanut butter pie is good and it looks so delicious. I just love normal cookies flavor so I'm not sure if I will gonna like it if its a form of cookies since I much enjoy eating pies.
Posted by nekonieden on 12-09-2018
amelia88

So indulgent!

Peanut butter pie is amazing. I love the rich creamy taste - it really feels incredibly indulgent. It’s also great when you’re entertaining since it just looks lovely on a dish! It’s always been super popular when I’ve made it!
Posted by amelia88 on 12-08-2018
theresajane

Love Pies

I don't know why but I don't really like cookies. I prefer pies and I love eating them whenever wherever. Well, maybe, it's because of the texture. For this one, even though I love peanut butter as a whole, I will go with peanut butter pie. Just imagining it makes me hungry.
Posted by theresajane on 12-09-2018
achikeziah

Pie

I choose peanut butter pie. I have not tasted this yet. It looks so delicious.
Posted by achikeziah on 12-09-2018
jessie271

Peanut Butter Pie

Peanut butte pie is not just delicious but also more filling than peanut butter cookies. It goes perfect with coffee and it can ease your hunger instantly as well as satisfy your sweet cravings. Peanut butter cookies, on the other hand, are perfect for easy-to-grab snacks.
Posted by jessie271 on 12-16-2018
antonToledo

I love pie!

Peanut butter pie and peanut butter cookies are both irresistible. both are very delicious but if I would cast my vote I would go with pie simply because I love pie than cookies!
Posted by antonToledo on 12-09-2018
Klint

Pie

I really love peanut butter pie. It's not that hard to make and it's actually pretty tasty and creamy. I love peanut butter pie.
Posted by Klint on 12-18-2018

46%

Peanut Butter Cookies

Peanut Butter Cookies
Who can resist a peanut butter cookie topped with a Hershey kiss? I know that I can not. This is a treat that has been around for years. Many will make it at the holidays as this was a cookie that perhaps their grandmothers or moms made for them. I know that every year this is always a cookie that my aunt makes for all of us.

What I love about these cookies is that the peanut butter is not overpowering. There is just enough of a peanutty taste that it will leave you wanting another bite. Pair it up with an ice cold glass of milk, and you have yourself a great little snack.

Pros
  • great to eat on the go
  • perfect old-time cookie
  • great blend of peanut butter and chocolate
  • can be stored on the counter makes a great gift perfect for a bake sale
  • great for the holidays *sweet
  • indulgent

Cons
  • hard to eat just one

Supporters

cmoneyspinner

Prefer Pie Over Cookies Except When ...

I prefer pies over cookies except when the main ingredient is peanut butter. Peanut butter as a pie? Nope. Not for me.
Posted by cmoneyspinner on 12-11-2018
iambeth

Cookie Monster

I love eating cookies! Need I say more?
Posted by iambeth on 12-09-2018
YoloBoy

COOKIES!!!

I just love eating cookies but adding peanut butter on it makes it even MORE great to eat. I love eating cookies when I am on the mood to chill or just watch some cooking shows or movies. Eating butter cookies is really something sweet and also creamy at the same time. Especially those kinds of cookies where you break it open and the peanut butter is just there oozing out.
Posted by YoloBoy on 12-12-2018
kaushikangara

Cookies

I like cookies more. They are crunchier and more tasty than the pie. Loads of peanut butter inside them makes them even more tastier. I usually buy cookies in bulk and keep munching on them in my leisure time. Besides that, butter cookies are always delicious.
Posted by kaushikangara on 12-09-2018
knnon

Cookies

I'm allergic to peanuts LOL! I developed this allergy a few years back. I'm still going to give an opinion since I did get to taste and consume a lot of peanuts before my allergy got triggered. Cookies are my favorite thing in the world to snack on, so definitely choosing this.
Posted by knnon on 12-09-2018
mcnasci24
I love homemade cookies! And I bet there's nothing better than feeling the aroma of freshly baked peanut butter cookies in the morning. With a cup of hot chocolate, it's heaven.
pencilneckgeek

I am the tiebreaker! Cookies!

I would have to choose peanut butter cookies as I am not a dessert person and I also don't like sweets that much. Cookies are much more tolerable for me and it is more handy so you can bring it with you and pop one when you are craving for a quick snack.
Posted by pencilneckgeek on 12-12-2018

Comments

mhingnhormz
Peanut Butter Cookies is good specially this coming christmas for a gift to specially to the children since most of them don't behave on the same place during this kind celebration, they will surely enjoy eating this kind of finger food aside from the hershey design chocolate on the top of the cookie, they will carry it anywhere they go while doing some stuffs.
Posted by mhingnhormz on 12-09-2018
theresajane
I love peanut butter and I love pies. For some reason, I don't like the texture of cookies. So, I'm choosing Peanut Butter Pies! I am even craving for it now.
Posted by theresajane on 12-09-2018
mcnasci24
Peanut butter cookies! They are easy to make, delicious to eat. My whole family likes them very much.
Posted by mcnasci24 on 12-09-2018
Frank
I agree with you cookies doesn't take much preparation time and cook time too is very limited too. Nice way of keeping the family together
Posted by Frank on 12-09-2018
gutzman
Both looks yummy but if I have to choose one, I'll go for Peanut Butter Pie because it looks more tasty. I also love the pies and their texture when you eat it. Most of them are not that sweet compared to cookies. In terms of which will last the most, I think the cookies will.
Posted by gutzman on 12-09-2018
theresajane
The same with me. I love the taste of peanut butter, but, I don't enjoy peanut butter cookies because of it's texture. I just love pies.
Posted by theresajane on 12-14-2018
achikeziah
I choose the pie. I have not seen this yet in our place. I can open a business that sells peanut butter pie.
Posted by achikeziah on 12-09-2018
iambeth
I don't like pies as much as I like cookies. I like eating those with a crunchy outer layer and a soft inner part. Yum!
Posted by iambeth on 12-09-2018
Frank
I just love cookies like that. So anything associated with cookies is all mine. I indulge cookies alot so the ones that will be made with peanut butter will be awesome. I will go for it.
Posted by Frank on 12-09-2018
antonToledo
After seeing this Post I got hungry and I want to eat a peanut butter! I hope it is easy to make even for a beginner like me.
Posted by antonToledo on 12-09-2018
theresajane
Well, it's easy if you have the equipments. Sadly, for me, we don't have an oven. But, I'm still thankful that our school gave us a chance to learn how to bake.
Posted by theresajane on 12-14-2018
Corzhens
Peanut butter is part of our culture although times have changed and peanut butter had lost its popularity. However I still see some bottles of American peanut butter in the supermarket which means there are still consumers of peanut butter. But there is one competitor that is giving peanut butter a run for its money. The Nutella is one product that came to the market a few years ago and I think it is good.
Posted by Corzhens on 12-11-2018
pencilneckgeek
Ever since I was a child, the peanut butter flavor of Ritz bits has been my favorite cookie. I would always buy one when we go grocery shopping. In recent years it became less and less available. It has been years since I ate one and this post now has me craving for them. Gotta go find them cookies!
Posted by pencilneckgeek on 12-12-2018