Versus

69%

Taylor Swift

Taylor Swift
Taylor Swift is a contemporary singer and song writer, who has written many songs that are reflections of her personal life. She released her first ever music album in the year 2006, and became one of the youngest winners of the Album of the year for her second album “Fearless”. Her numbers such as “I knew you were Trouble”, and “Look what you made me do” are extremely popular. Her songs are mostly crossovers between pop and country music. She has won many awards, including 4 Grammy awards, 21 Billboard Music Awards, and an Emmy Award etc. Presently, she is one of the most well-known names in the music industry, with ample wealth as well.

Pros
  1. Her songs are reflective and melodious;
  2. She is a singer who has perfected her music and is not successful because she is singing trendy music because she is quite unique in her own way. She is able to combine pop, country, and pop rock beautifully.
  3. She is into charities and other philanthropic works.
  4. She is aware that her fans are influenced by her behavior so she does not go overboard. She does voice her opinions on issues such as LGBT and campaigns against “hate crimes”.

Cons
  1. She does have a personal life, which media does report, and which does not really show her in the best light, though she refuses to comment on it.

Supporters

angie828

Taylor

Not that I am a huge fan of either one, but if I had to pick, Taylor would be it. She has the better music in my opinion. Yes Miley may have a catchy song or two, but Taylor's music is better, and I think that she just sings better all around. I rarely listen to her, but if I am at a wedding or party and her songs play, I can dance to them easily.
Posted by angie828 on 11-05-2017
kgord

Taylor Swift

I think Taylor Swift has a lot more talent than Miley Cyrus. Cyrus may have a strong voice but her musicality seems to be lacking. I don't like Cyrus as I think she is a poor role model for the young girls who used to look up to her as Hannah Montana.
Posted by kgord on 11-06-2017
cmoneyspinner

Swift is Swifter i.e. Really Savvy and Smart

Not a fan of either one. I'm probably too old to appreciate them. Miley Cyrus never made an impression on me. Not as Hannah Montana, a TV show I know because I watched it with my granddaughter. There's nothing outstanding about what she's doing now either.

What I admire about Ms. Swift is her business savvyness or shrewdness. She lives up to her name. She's swift! She's not just a singer. She's a smart business woman and she started on her journey at a very young age, making serious decisions as if she were a top business exec like Bill Gates. When I was her age I wasn't making weighty decisions like that! Also, I can at least remember some of her songs, even though songs by both of these ladies are “childish” by my musical tastes. Like I said … I'm probably too old to appreciate them.

Posted by cmoneyspinner on 12-14-2017
JoeMilford

Swift Is Better?

I must admit that I really do not like either of these recording artists, but if choosing between the two, I would choose Taylor Swift. She does, from what I understand, write a lot of her own material and most of her own lyrics, and obviously, whether you think she is talented or not, she is doing something which the popular culture likes enough to make her famous, loved, and rich beyond belief. She also seems to be a bit more earnest about entertaining that Cyrus; however, this might be an unfair judgment on my part. In terms of actual vocal prowess, I'd say Miley has a better range, but, for me, between the two, Swift has more to offer.
Posted by JoeMilford on 11-06-2017
Wyvh

Better songs.

I still and honestly feel like Miley is still needing to find her own style, whereas Taylor Swift has her own. And talking about popularity.. well, don't need to add anything here. :)
Posted by Wyvh on 11-05-2017
NickJ

Not a big of either but in this versus I choose Ta

I think the quality of Taylor's music is far better than Miley's. Also Miley has had some pretty bad performances at awards shows. Particularly the MTV Awards show where she did that unsettling 'dance number' (if you wanna call it that) with Robin Thicke.
Posted by NickJ on 11-05-2017
Martinsx

Taylor Swift

Taylor Swift is among my favorite musicians. Some of her love pop songs are very touching and soothing.

I still listen to her songs today and they still remind me of how good she still is at her music life.

Posted by Martinsx on 11-14-2018
superlicca

Love her

I have been a fan of Taylor Swift since I heard her song "Teardrops on my guitar". She is really beautiful and I like her humble personality. Her songs are really amazing and I can play her songs everyday. She is a better singer than the other.
Posted by superlicca on 11-21-2018
jeffreyjose48

Taylor Swift

I vote for Taylor Swift. She is a good singer. I also like her songs.
Posted by jeffreyjose48 on 11-01-2018
emiaj55

T swift still

Controversies aside, T-Swifts songs are marked by passionate artistry. They are really very relatable, other being light while others have a pinch in the heart.
Posted by emiaj55 on 11-24-2018
Einalem

It's definitely Taylor Swift

Both of them are great singers, as well as songwriters. However, Taylor Swift didn't just recieved those awards for nothing. Between the two of them, I prefer Taylor. I love how she writes her songs, and changing from country to pop songs isn't easy. She made a huge mark in the music industry, and I'll continue to listen to her songs.
Posted by Einalem on 11-01-2018

31%

Miley Cyrus

Miley Cyrus
Miley Cyrus is a very young American pop song writer, actress and singer. She shot to fame in 2006 with her role as Hannah Montana on Disney channel, which was subsequently made into a movie. She has released albums such as “Meet Miley Cyrus” and “Can’t be Tamed”. She was also a music coach on “The Voice”. Though she has not won any Grammy awards as yet, her music does sell. Basically she is into pop music, though she does try to blend it some. Her personal life interests many and she does have a bold way of going about it. Like many celebrities, she has lent her support to the LGBT community. But she has also a few eyebrow raising behaviors to her credit while transitioning into her role as an adult celebrity. People seem to be interested in her religious beliefs, and sexual life. She is also into philanthropy like most celebrities.

Pros
  1. She is young and therefore, her beliefs would still need to be well thought out and she would have to understand that fans do get influenced;
  2. She sings very well.

Cons
  1. She has done some shocking things.

Supporters

kingcool52

Miley

Neither really, I think there are a lot of better female artists and role models out there. But if I had to choose then I would probably go with Miley Cyrus. She did have a bit of a crazy phase but it seems that she is back to normal now and behaving like an actual role model to her young fans. Taylor Swift is just a bit too crazy and also tends to go a bit overboard with things.
Posted by kingcool52 on 11-05-2017
Sue

Miley

I have never been a fan of Taylor Swift. I just do not care for her at all as an artist or as a person. I have seen her in interviews many times and she comes across as very arrogant. She is an okay singer but Miley is by far a better singer and far more talented in my opinion. She is a nicer person and more down to earth.
Posted by Sue on 11-08-2017
wiseagent

I pick Miley.

A few years ago I would have answered Taylor Swift because I really thought she was a good singer and an interesting person (but she has turned out to be a very fake person). So, I choose Miley Cyrus because she's more authentic and genuine.
Posted by wiseagent on 11-06-2017
thejoyrevolution

For the voice

I love how Miley Cyrus sounds. She actually has a good tone. I used to love Taylor Swift’s songs. I’ve listen to her since Teardrops on my Guitar. But Miley’s song now is better for me. It is catchy regardless of how she looks or acts you can’t deny she has a great voice.
Posted by thejoyrevolution on 11-07-2018
sonnyisabeast

Cool over Boring

Miley is just simply much cooler than Taylor "I fell asleep just looking at her face" Swift. Taylor has good songs but there is just something about her face that's so boring and unforgettable. Miley can do all of Taylor's videos and she'd look good in all of them. Can you imagine Taylor in Wrecking Ball?
Posted by sonnyisabeast on 11-07-2018

Comments

Pink_Turtle
I like them both, they got pretty cool and catchy songs. But Miley got better vocals. I had the opportunity to hear Taylor live and it sounds nothing like in the records. They both got different styles and they are both very controversial in different ways. I think Miley has a more open personality which is great for me because she shows herself as she is. Taylor has some shade on her when it comes to her personality because many people claimed she doesn't show herlself the way she really is.
Posted by Pink_Turtle on 11-04-2017
Alexa
Neither to be honest. They are both young, fairly talented but have tapped into the youth market where they can influence young fans to buy anything they are associated with. I think like Britney Spears they will feel the burn out when they do get married or have children and their lives with have to change. Right now they are very free to work on projects they wish and don't need to think about money.
Posted by Alexa on 11-05-2017
babyright
I think Taylor Swift is a very talented musician than Cyrus. She also helps the poor though some still try to find her faults, nobody is perfect but she will be the best as the years goes by.
Posted by babyright on 11-05-2017
ColdFlameChris
I don't like them both because of their attitude. Taylor Swift is a gorgeous woman but her attitude is not that good, while Miley Cyrus looks like on drugs or something, for me. I never listen to both of their music and doesn't have a plan to do so.
Posted by ColdFlameChris on 11-05-2017
Tania997
I feel the same way. Taylor swift looks good but I don't like her as a person, and Miley Cyrus.. I've never been a fan of her and this new persona she has adopted only made me hate her honestly. People look up to her as someone who demonstrates what being free is like, but I don't see it that way and the fact she's influencing young people is bad.
Posted by Tania997 on 11-05-2017
felabruno
I'm not a fan of either of them. I think I'm not the target for them, their fans are teenage girls I assume. I have heard some calmer, country-pop songs from Miley and I liked them but Taylor Swift has always bored me. Both are very manufactured and unlikeable.
Posted by felabruno on 11-05-2017
vinaya
I did not like the child artist Miley Cyrus. I did not like Miley Cyrus when she suddenly became adult. I don't like her music and I don't like her persona. I don't listen to the type of music that taylo Swift creates, however, I have listened to her music and I liked some of her songs. I find Taylor Swift very beautiful
Posted by vinaya on 11-05-2017
Mehano
Neither really so I won't vote. I don't listen to their music or follow their personal lives. I do know the major scandals though since a few of them were all over the news, particular Miley Cyrus's ones. But regardless, they got have a huge fanbase and their supporters will love them no matter what which is all that matters. They make music for the fans and I am not one of them so my opinion is invalid.
Posted by Mehano on 11-06-2017
lovely
I have never adored any if these two because I believe in better celebrities than these two but for this purpose I think I will ho for Miley Cyrus. I try a bit to like her movies, maybe her philanthropic life but her craziness is so overwhelming to be a role model but I believe she Better in my own assessment than Taylor.
Posted by lovely on 11-06-2017
Scarlet
I prefer Taylor Swift because of her fashion and style which never changed through the years. Miley Cyrus on the other hand had cute fashion and trend from the start but begun changing her looks and styles through the years that somehow made her changed her beautiful and sweet image.
Posted by Scarlet on 11-08-2017
Scarlet
I prefer Taylor Swift because of her fashion and style which never changed through the years. Miley Cyrus on the other hand had cute fashion and trend from the start but begun changing her looks and styles through the years that somehow made her changed her beautiful and sweet image.
Posted by Scarlet on 11-08-2017
mildredtabitha
I like both of them although I would choose Taylor swift because I like her music. She is decent and knows how to influence her fans. You can feel her music and can also identify with her story.
Posted by mildredtabitha on 11-08-2017
chatbox
For this versus, I would pick Taylor Swift because she does sing and write songs well and relies on her talents to maintain her popularity. She's the type who'll stay for the long haul if she continues to make music. Miley Cyrus had turned me off when she marked her transformation from child to adult artist with disgusting behavior. She has a unique voice and she would have soared with it sans her attention-getting antics.
Posted by chatbox on 12-09-2017
Corzhens
I am not really a fan of Miley Cyrus but I like her in some movies that I have seen. Maybe because she looks like one of our family friends. To be honest, I don’t remember the titles of the movies I had seen where Miley Cyrus had a role but I remember her great acting. With her songs, I also love some of it but not Wrecking Ball, definitely not because to me, that song had ruined her image.
Posted by Corzhens on 02-05-2018
jeffreyjose48
I choose Taylor Swift. She is a beautiful and great singer. I like to listen to her songs.
Posted by jeffreyjose48 on 11-01-2018
ivandelrey
Musically I prefer Taylor Swift, I bought her last 2 albums because 1. It's Pop and 2. They were once available only on iTunes so I had no choice but to purchase them. She knows how to win the younger audience by making super catchy songs and that's part of her brand. I don't really care about the drama surrounding her, I don't personally know her or any other famous people so I can't comment on that part.
Posted by ivandelrey on 12-10-2018